Wedding catering is not just about picking the menu that suits your budget. You need to choose the dinner style (sit-down, buffet, and others), drinks, presentation, and more.

It would help if you had a catering team with experience working with different couples and with varying budgets. Here are the top options in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

ZHG has been bringing joy and class to hundreds of weddings for the past 50 years. The team has experienced chefs, cooking professionals, and helpers to bring out exceptional food. You can choose buffets, interactive stations, plated dinner, passed small bites, or small plate dining. You can also choose from different cuisines or tailor-fit the menu for your choices. Are you looking for ethnically-perfect food for your wedding? ZHG is famous for Indian menus, kosher foods, and more.

Address: 613 N Grandview Blvd, Waukesha, WI 53188

Phone: (262) 547-9447

Social: Zilli Hospitality Group

Profile: Zilli Hospitality Group


Contact : Ellen

Tall Guy and a Grill offers fresh farm-to-table menu items and a passionate team to serve the same during your wedding. You can choose a seasonal menu to add indigenous seasonal ingredients based on the time of your wedding. The team offers a large menu with different options for appetizers, greens, entrees, meat, seafood, tacos, sides, desserts, and more. You can mix-and-match based on your budget. If you are pushing your wedding to late-night, you can also choose late-night snacks, a hot bar, and more.

Address: 6733 W Lincoln Ave, West Allis, WI 53219

Phone: (414) 777-0770

Social: Tall Guy and a Grill

Profile: Tall Guy and a Grill


Contact : Dan

Armon’s Catering is the right choice for both extravaganza weddings and small intimate ceremonies. You can choose between banquet & upscale and standard catering services. The former option gives you a variety of choices like passed appetizers, specialty stations, buffets, dinners, and more. The team also brings in flatware, chafing dishes, tables, linens, chairs, and more. In the second option, the team delivers the food, serving utensils, cutlery packs, plates, and tablecloths 15 minutes prior to your wedding. You can also opt for disposable steel warmers, flatware, tents, tables, and others.

Address: 9823 N Granville Rd, Mequon, WI 53097

Phone: (414) 803-5659

Social: Armon's Catering

Profile: Armon's Catering


Contact : Amir

Shully’s is a premium catering service provider who will guide you throughout the wedding catering process. The team will arrange everything from stage one so that you can work on other areas of your wedding. You can choose the Iron Fork Challenge for your engagement parties, which is similar to the TV cooking contest. You can split your party into two and let them cook in Shully’s kitchen, where ingredients and equipment are provided. Shully will be preparing the dessert. In the end, the staff would rank and score the dishes. The company also offers zero-contact catering services.

Address: 146 Green Bay Rd, Thiensville, WI 53092

Phone: (262) 242-6633

Social: Shully's Cuisine and Events

Profile: Shully's Cuisine and Events


Contact : Scott

You can cherry-pick from a variety of options, including barbeques. Chef’s table, Formal Buffets, and Plated Dinner are the three main types of options. Under each option, a large menu would be offered in which the couple can choose the best dishes of their choice. Beyond these, you can choose add ons like Bao Buns, Ramen Bar, Hors D’oeuvre (cold, hot, deluxe), late-night drinks, macho nacho bar, mini dessert station, soft pretzel bar, popcorn bar, sliders, and more. If you want a unique experience, you can choose from the specialty options like the Caribbean, cold sandwich buffet, south of the border buffet, and more.

Address: Big Bend, Wisconsin 53103

Phone: (262) 662-4201

Social: All Occasions Catering

Profile: All Occasions Catering


Contact : Rebecca

From Scratch Catering is famous for homemade recipes and multiple options. The team offers three main types of menu categories – Great Beginnings, Sweet Finale, Main Event, and Late Night Fare. Each type has different styles of items and courses. This team’s specialties are Mac N Cheese bar, stuffed beef tenderloins, and California Crostinis. You can also include a veggie and cheese platter bar. The team offers a wedding cake for the ceremony.

Address: W62 N563 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012

Phone: (262) 618-4661

Social: From Scratch Catering

Profile: From Scratch Catering


Contact : Donna

Brim Café and Catering is famous for offering a Mediterranean touch to your menu. Chef Michael Wahhab has traveled the world and is more than eager to bring in more flavors to your menu. You can also request special meals like specific family recipes, paleo meals, dairy-free meals, vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, and more. There are three different types of menus based on budget, and you can also opt for the family-style, in which the entire menu can be custom created by the couple. The menu also includes kids’ items, a late-night snack menu, a coffee/tea bar, and a wedding cake.

Address: Lower Level, 125 S 84th St, Milwaukee, WI 53214

Phone: (414) 774-9505

Social: Brim Cafe and Catering

Profile: Brim Cafe and Catering


Contact : Brittany

Lisa Kaye Catering offers catering services for small and large events. You can book the service for boxed lunches, a gala wedding, or a small cocktail reception. You can try the menu during the tasting, wherein you will be tasting request-specific dishes from the chosen menu. You can either choose the dishes of your choice from the menu or offer a budget for the chef to work with and create a custom menu for your event. The first step is, sitting down with the team and sharing your requirements.

Address: 944 N 33rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53208

Phone: (414) 751-8786

Social: Lisa Kaye Catering

Profile: Lisa Kaye Catering


Contact : Lisa

The chief chef was raised in a Jewish community and loves to offer a wide range of flavors and a variety of kosher dishes. The team uses fresh ingredients, and beyond the taste, the team takes pain in presenting the food in a beautiful way. There is no standard menu with Hannah’s Kitchen. You can sit with the chef and create a menu to suit your crowd and budget. The chef will also weigh in any opinion if required. You can be sure about home-styled quality food during your wedding.

Address: Glendale, WI

Phone: (414) 350-2086

Social: Hannah's Kitchen

Profile: Hannah's Kitchen


Contact : Hannah

You can pick from a wide range of options like platters, appetizers, fish station, salads, homemade spreads, fresh baguettes, desserts, and more. You can customize the menu based on the cost per person. If you desire, you can also choose gift baskets for your guests. Every ingredient is homegrown or sourced from local vendors. The team uses homemade butter, organic herbs, fresh cheese, and fruits for the menu.

Address: 3015 S 39th St, Milwaukee, WI 53215

Phone: (414) 704-5995

Social: My Family Roots Catering

Profile: My Family Roots Catering


Contact : Beth E





Back to Top

Conclusion

Catering can be a significant part of your wedding budget. If you’re planning to spend so much on a single vendor, you should be confident that the food you receive is both delicious and to your taste. 

Each of the options that we have listed promises delicious food that you will remember for the rest of your life. Make sure the caterer you choose offers your favorite cuisine and can work to create a menu that you will love. That said, regardless of whom you choose from our list, we’re sure you’ll be completely satisfied!



Back to Top