Specializing in offering customized delicious cakes, Fantasy Cakes is the best stop to find a wide collection of cakes with infinite flavors and fillings. The lead baker, Jelena, discovered her passion for baking in 2009 and established Fantasy Cakes in 2010 to turn her passion into a successful career. They offer cake tasting only for events with a guest list of at least 100 people, which starts at $15 for two guests, allowing you to select up to 3 cake options. Their cake prices begin at $4 per serving, and the final cost depends on the total gathering.

Address: 4550 S Brust Ave Milwaukee, WI 53235

Phone: 262-327-4745

Social: Fantasy Cakes

Profile: Fantasy Cakes

Contact : Jelena

Mia Stav Cakes is a custom cakery famous for offering modern, trendy, and designer cakes. From vanilla, lemon, red velvet, banana, chocolate to funfetti cakes, Mia can help you create a dream wedding cake by keeping all your needs in mind. They have a wide variety of wedding cakes, and your cake’s price depends on the decoration, number of servings, and other factors. They also offer a tasting box to try all cake flavors but only once a month on a fixed date.

Address: Milwaukee, WI

Social: Mia Stav Cakes

Profile: Mia Stav Cakes

Contact : Mia

Established in 2009, Classy Girl Cupcakes is a premier gourmet bakery owned and operated by Erica Elia. Made from scratch using homemade buttercream and fresh ingredients, all of their cakes are hand-crafted art pieces. From vegan cakes to gluten-free, vegan cakes to standard recipe cakes and others, they offer around 25 different flavors every day to fulfill your desires. Whatever design you have in your mind, their professional decorators can bring that to life.

Address: 825 N Jefferson St Milwaukee, WI 53202

Phone: 414-270-1877

Social: Classy Girl Cupcakes

Profile: Classy Girl Cupcakes

Contact : Erica Elia

Aggie’s Bakery & Cake Shop has been offering made to order, custom cakes for different occasions since 1977. As a family-owned business, all their talented bakers use tried-and-tested baking practices to make delicious cakes and other treats. They deliver a range of cakes and dessert options to decorate tables at the wedding, including tiered cakes, sheet cakes, table cakes, cheesecakes, cookies, and more. From chocolate, red velvet, yellow, marble, carrot, lemon to confetti, you will find any and every flavor that delights your tastebuds.

Address: 7328 W Greenfield Ave West Allis, WI 53214

Phone: 414-482-1288

Social: Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop

Profile: Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop

Contact : Rachel Schmidbauer

Initially founded by Simma in 1982, Peggy and Mark Carollo are the current owners of the bakery. They have been recognized all across the region for their delicious wedding cakes, cheesecakes, pastries, and other desserts for over 35 years. Their talented chefs use the purest ingredients and cutting-edge practices for baking truly superior cakes. No matter your desired wedding cake size or shape, the team has baked and crafted countless scrumptious cakes for couples with varying tastes. 

Address: 817 N 68th St Wauwatosa, WI 53213

Phone: 414-257-0998

Social: Simma's Bakery

Profile: Simma's Bakery

Contact : Mark Carollo

Founded in 2002, Sweet Perfections Bake Shoppe is a family-owned, specialty cake business. Ken and Peggy, owners of this bakery, believe in incredible tastes, exquisite presentation, and high-end customer service. Therefore, they are committed to delivering unique, traditional, and sculpted wedding cakes – a combination of your desired flavors and fillings. Though they have endless cake options with varying rates, the last price depends on the cake style, display, flavor, filling, and the number of servings.

Address: 1501 Paramount Dr, Ste C Waukesha, WI 53186

Phone: 262-446-2253

Social: Sweet Perfections Bake Shoppe

Profile: Sweet Perfections Bake Shoppe

Contact : Ken & Peggy

Grebe’s Bakery is a family-owned bakery founded by Irene Grene in 1937 in her home kitchen. From engagements to weddings to any other celebrations, their specialists can help you bake and design delicious and customized cakes to make those sweet moments unforgettable. Their menu displays a great collection of themed and novelty wedding cakes; all of them are made using fresh, high-quality ingredients for a flavorful taste. They also offer cake tasting appointments so that you can give a try to different options to finalize your wedding cake.

Address: 5132 W Lincoln Ave West Allis, WI 53219

Phone: 414-543-7000

Social: Grebe's Bakery

Profile: Grebe's Bakery

Contact : Grebe

Cecelia Baker Grade, the current owner, works with couples to craft individually designed wedding cakes that showcase their unique styles and tastes. Cecelia bought this bakery from Karen Smith in 2018 and is giving her best to exceed people’s expectations by offering customized cakes. No matter your needs, all their cakes are layered where sheet cake starts at $3 per serving and tiered cakes begin at $4 per serving. Moreover, with tasting appointments for five different cake flavors, they offer you the opportunity to pick the best one from vanilla, lavender, spice, red velvet, and lavender cake.

Address: 3561 S Kinnickinnic Ave St. Francis, WI 53235

Phone: 414-294-4220

Social: The Cake Lady

Profile: The Cake Lady

Contact : Cecelia

Everything from full cakes to bite-sized pastries, Sweet Tooth specializes in freshly baked, homemade wedding cakes. Pam and Brianna use only locally-sourced ingredients and creative designs to create one-of-a-kind cakes to cater for large wedding celebrations. They offer tasting samples for two guests with a consultation fee of $20, allowing them to choose up to 5 options of their choice from the listing. The total cake cost varies depending on your particular demands, with additional charges for custom cakes.

Address: 7227 W North Avenue Wauwatosa, WI 53213

Phone: 262-789-0500

Social: Sweet Tooth

Profile: Sweet Tooth

Contact : Brianna

The team at Canfora Bakery specializes in real whipped cream cakes and offers a wide range of flavors and fillings. Flavors include cassata cake, chocolate raspberry shadow cake, red velvet cake, and more while filling options include pineapple, lemon, rum custard, coconut cream, and more.

The bakery also offers a custom wedding cake option, where you can build your own wedding cake to suit your tastebuds. If you’re considering Canfora Cakes for your wedding day, you can also make an appointment for a cake tasting. At the tasting, you will receive four different flavors to try.

Address: 1100 E Oklahoma Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207

Phone: 414-486-7747

Social: Canfora Bakery

Contact : Canfora Bakery Team

Back to Top


Your wedding cake is going to be a centerpiece of your big day. This list of the top 10 cake bakers in Milwaukee can help you find the best baker for your wedding. Go through all these options to make the right choice.

Back to Top