Top 14 Best Wedding Cake Bakers in Indianapolis, IN (2023)
When it comes to wedding cakes, the only limitations on taste and design seem to be your own imagination. Gone are the days that a simple vanilla sponge is expected, and it’s far in the past that fruit cake is the norm. Today, we have seen flavor pairings like pink champagne and strawberry, peanut butter and chocolate, and even Matcha green tea.
We recommend that you pick a wedding cake, and a wedding cake baker, that makes you happy. Don’t worry about trying to satisfy everyone’s sweet tooth, but rather make your cake show off your and your new spouse’s preferences. From the flavors on the inside to the decorations on the outside, wow your guests with your eccentricity and make a delicious statement.
Best Wedding Cakes In Indianapolis
Tanya Marshall has been the owner of Heavenly Sweets Cakes since its inception over twenty-five years ago. It all started simply because she couldn’t find a high-quality cake to buy, so she decided to open up the market. To this day, the ethos of only using high-quality, premium ingredients and baking in small batches continues to ensure her cakes are amongst the very best in Indianapolis. Tanya is even a grand prize winner on Food Network’s Clash of the Grandma’s, where her dessert won over the judges. Cakes start at $4.50 per serving, and cake tastings can be arranged by appointment to ensure personalized service.
Address: 293 S. 8th Street, Noblesville, IN 46060
Social: Heavenly Sweets Cakes
Profile: Heavenly Sweets Cakes
Founded in 1995, Classic Cakes continues to specialize in extraordinary custom cakes and cupcakes. They offer complimentary cake tastings by appointment, but be sure to show up with an empty belly. You’ll have about a dozen different flavors to try and can request particular favorites with advance notice. After you’ve eaten a lot of dessert at your tasting session, you’ll be able to walk away with an individualized quote based on your guest numbers, wedding cake flavor, and design preferences. Classic Cakes offer various allergy-friendly and restricted diet options from vegan cakes to cakes without eggs, nuts, soy, sugar, gluten, dyes, or dairy.
Address: 1752 E 116th Street, Carmel, IN 46032
Social: Classic Cakes
Profile: Classic Cakes
Taylor’s Bakery has a history that we love to read about in America, but are becoming increasingly difficult to come by. Taylor’s Bakery’s original Taylor was an honest family man who worked hard and started his own neighborhood business back in 1913. Fast forward over one hundred years, and it is now the fourth generation running the show at their two Indianapolis locations. All wedding cakes are baked fresh and never refrigerated or frozen, and Taylor’s Bakery is even happy to take last minute orders up to the day before your wedding, that’s if you book them at the right time.
Address: 6216 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Social: Taylor's Bakery
Profile: Taylor's Bakery
Since opening their doors in 2007, the response has been phenomenal, and The Flying Cupcake has quickly expanded into five different city locations. Quite obviously, they make stunning cupcakes and have the cutest bride and groom cupcakes, one with white frills and pearls and the other with a tuxedo and bowtie. Expect cakes, cupcakes, and desserts that are delicious and make people happy when they see them. Tiered cakes start at $255 for a 3-tier cake with an additional $65 decorating charge. Gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegan cakes can be arranged, so no one needs to be left out of the fun.
Address: 5617 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Social: The Flying Cupcake
Profile: The Flying Cupcake
This talented wedding cake baker in Indianapolis can create custom cakes of all shapes, sizes, and themes. From piping and damask patterns to sugar flowers and monograms, you can have all of the special touches you desire. Kim’s Kakery, Bakery & Café always uses made-from-scratch real-butter buttercream for the best flavors. Signature options include chocolate fudge, almond/amaretto flavors, whipped cream cakes, and more. Since 2010, this small business has focused on delivering exceptional customer service. Rave reviews describe moist cake, homemade buttercream, and custom options. The dedicated team has 60 years of experience in baking and decorating. Ask Kim’s Kakery, Bakery & Café about tasty treats like cookies, bars, cupcakes, pastries, and pies. Gluten-free choices are also available.
Address: 5452 Madison Ave Indianapolis, IN 46227
Facebook: Kim's Kakery, Bakery & Café
Instagram: Kim's Kakery, Bakery & Café
Expect superior service and personalized attention when you work with this family-owned business. With over 30 years of experience, Marsha’s Specialty Desserts & Tierney’s Catering opened in 2010 and quickly became a top-rated favorite. These wedding cake bakers in Indianapolis offer a plethora of shapes, sizes, and themes. You can select the flavor of the cake and icing from orange, french vanilla, milk chocolate, and more. Fillings include lime, lemon, peach, cherry, mocha, and others. You can pick decorations like flowers, scrollwork, ribbons, and unique details. Gourmet cupcakes are also available. Ask about delicious options like chocolate cinnamon streusel, orange cream dream, pineapple whip, strawberries n’ cream, and many more.
Address: 10834 E US Highway 36 Avon, IN 46123
For over two decades, Sweet Seductions have been providing Indianapolis with wedding cakes on par with any of the top cities in America. Cake tastings and consultations are free of charge, and they are happy to work with you to design a cake that perfectly meshes with your wedding colors, theme, and style. Whether you would like simple and understated or elaborately detailed with a multitude of colors, Sweet Seductions can make it happen.
Address: 10965 E County Rd 700 S, Camby, IN 46113
Social: Sweet Seductions
Profile: Sweet Seductions
Cindy Hawkins is the pastry chef and owner of Circle City Sweets that can be found in the Historic City Market Building in downtown Indianapolis. They are available for tasting sessions, and in addition to a wide variety of cake options, they are famous for their decorated sugar cookies, french macarons, and caramels that make delicious wedding favors.
Address: 222 E Market St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Social: Circle City Sweets
Profile: Circle City Sweets
Alana Cobb is the self-taught decorating extraordinaire at Princess Confections who mixes her God-given talents with her love for pushing the boundaries regarding flavor and design. Her degree in Restaurant Management complements her many artistic skills. Whether you want one, two, or even six tiers on your wedding cake, we know that Princess Confections can deliver it beautifully and exceed expectations. Cakes start at $3.50 per slice for buttercream or $4.50 for fondant. A 20% deposit is required to secure your date, with the remainder of the payment due three weeks before your big day.
Address: 10609 E Washington St Suite F, Indianapolis, IN 46229
Social: Princess Confections
Profile: Princess Confections
Gwendolyn Rogers is the creative talent behind The Cake Bake Shop. With years of experience, unique designs, and delicious flavors, you can trust this top cake baker in Indianapolis to handcraft your perfect wedding cake. Tasty options include raspberry champagne cake, lemon blueberry, german chocolate, and much more. Elegant cake toppers and cake stands are also available from The Cake Bake Shop. Ask about other yummy desserts such as macarons, cookies, cheesecake, brownies, pies, and more. Gluten-free options are available from this recommended Indianapolis wedding cake baker. This award-winning bakery is opening a shop at Walt Disney World Resort because it’s just that good!
Address: 6515 Carrollton Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Facebook: The Cake Bake Shop
Instagram: The Cake Bake Shop
Sweet Escape Cake Company is an Indianapolis-based takeaway and delivery bakery. They specialize in wedding and celebration cakes, as well as cupcakes and cake pops. Wedding cakes start at $4 per slice for buttercream decorated cakes with one flavor and one filling. White chocolate fondant cakes start at $4.25 per serving. Have a look through their gallery of photos, and you’ll notice their variety and flexibility in design styles from simple to ornate.
Address: 7745 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46217
Social: Sweet Escape Cake Company
Profile: Sweet Escape Cake Company
Say yes to a specialty cake or custom cupcakes from Eats by Chef Mel for your celebration. Mel is a professional chef-turned-baker with over 20+ years of experience. With a formal education from a culinary arts school in Chicago, you can trust her creative vision and baking skills to deliver delicious and picture-perfect desserts. You can pick your favorite flavors and design, so your cake fits your wedding theme. Ask about a dessert table complete with cupcakes, baked cake donuts, cocoa bombs, cake pops, and other sweet treats. You and your guests will love the scrumptious desserts as you celebrate your love. Mel is ready to listen to your requests and tickle your taste buds.
Address: Carmel, IN
Facebook: Eats by Chef Mel
Instagram: Eats by Chef Mel
Pastry chef Ben Hardy and Alison Keefer came together to open the Gallery Pastry Shop in Indianapolis. The company specializes in European pastries and decadent plated desserts. Wedding cake decorating trends like hand-painted scenes, marbling, and drip cakes are gorgeously executed with added detailing of macrons, gold leaf, and chocolate bark. The best part is that Gallery Pastry Shop is always up for collaborating on new and exciting flavor combinations, so feel free to ask them anything. Cake tastings can be arranged by appointment, as can cake delivery and set up.
Address: 1101 E 54th Street, Suite G, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Social: Gallery Pastry Shop
Profile: Gallery Pastry Shop
Gabby’s Cakes is a bespoke wedding cake and cupcake baker that has been in business since 2017. Gabby will go all-in for your wedding, and as a small business, taking pride ensures that each and every couple gets 110% of her attention and devotion. The cakes are modern and understated, with clean lines and just the right pop of color. Speak to her about collaborating on something that you can be assured your guests will remember for years to come.
Address: 2442 Central Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Social: Gabby’s Cakes
Profile: Gabby’s Cakes
The wedding cake bakers on our list in Indianapolis can satisfy anyone’s craving for chocolate or vanilla. However, if you are interested in raising the wedding cake flavor meter a notch, then speak to them about exciting pairings that harmoniously mesh the individual tastes of you and your fiancé.
Is your business featured in this article?
Copy the code below and place the code on your website to display the badge award on your website.