Indianapolis, IN

Tanya Marshall has been the owner of Heavenly Sweets Cakes since its inception over twenty-five years ago. It all started simply because she couldn’t find a high-quality cake to buy, so she decided to open up the market. To this day, the ethos of only using high-quality, premium ingredients and baking in small batches continues to ensure her cakes are amongst the very best in Indianapolis. Tanya is even a grand prize winner on Food Network’s Clash of the Grandma’s, where her dessert won over the judges. Cakes start at $4.50 per serving, and cake tastings can be arranged by appointment to ensure personalized service.

Address: 293 S. 8th Street, Noblesville, IN 46060

Phone: 317-770-9399

Social: Heavenly Sweets Cakes

Profile: Heavenly Sweets Cakes

Contact : Tanya Marshall

Founded in 1995, Classic Cakes continues to specialize in extraordinary custom cakes and cupcakes. They offer complimentary cake tastings by appointment, but be sure to show up with an empty belly. You’ll have about a dozen different flavors to try and can request particular favorites with advance notice. After you’ve eaten a lot of dessert at your tasting session, you’ll be able to walk away with an individualized quote based on your guest numbers, wedding cake flavor, and design preferences. Classic Cakes offer various allergy-friendly and restricted diet options from vegan cakes to cakes without eggs, nuts, soy, sugar, gluten, dyes, or dairy.

Address: 1752 E 116th Street, Carmel, IN 46032

Phone: 317-844-6901

Social: Classic Cakes

Profile: Classic Cakes

Contact : Megan Ritz

Taylor’s Bakery has a history that we love to read about in America, but are becoming increasingly difficult to come by. Taylor’s Bakery’s original Taylor was an honest family man who worked hard and started his own neighborhood business back in 1913. Fast forward over one hundred years, and it is now the fourth generation running the show at their two Indianapolis locations. All wedding cakes are baked fresh and never refrigerated or frozen, and Taylor’s Bakery is even happy to take last minute orders up to the day before your wedding, that’s if you book them at the right time.

Address: 6216 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Phone: 317-251-9575

Social: Taylor's Bakery

Profile: Taylor's Bakery

Contact : Drew & Matt

View more wedding cakes in indianapolis