Magnolia Bakery has been dishing out sweet treats since 1996 and found worldwide fame when featured on the iconic New York-based show, Sex, and the City. Since then, they have franchised, and their creations have appeared multiple times on TV and in print. Magnolia Bakery is kosher certified and does have a limited amount of gluten-free options. The Cake Salon can make traditional tiered cakes, sheet cakes, or one of our new favorite trends, deconstructed cakes that come together to form a stunning display. Customized cupcakes and cookies can be individually wrapped and make ideal wedding favors.

Address: New York, NY

Phone: 855-622-5379

Social: Magnolia Bakery

Profile: Magnolia Bakery

Contact : Steve Abrams

No list of the top wedding cake bakers in New York City would be complete without mention of Ron Ben-Israel Cakes. A genius baker whose spark was ignited by watching his Viennese mother whipping up sweet confections as a child, Ron Ben-Israel is now an international leader. This couture bakery was founded in 1999 and came onto the world stage when Ben-Israel was picked to judge both the Sweet Genius and Cake Wars shows on Food Network. With this bakery, there is no doubt your cake will be an exceptional work of art.

Address: 247 West 38th St, Floor 13, New York, NY 10018

Phone: 212-625-3369

Social: Ron Ben-Israel Cakes

Profile: Ron Ben-Israel Cakes

Contact : Ron Ben-Israel

City Cakes is well-deserving of their place on our list of best wedding cake bakers in New York City. Affordability, artistry, and flavor blend into a surreal portfolio of wedding cake options. Whether you would prefer a simple white cake with traditional flowers and pearls or a hand-painted garden scene, City Cakes will make it happen. Flavor options include Almond Wonder, Strawberry Champagne, and Lush Amaretto, to mention just a few of our stand-out favorites. Pair that with one of their seventeen buttercream flavors, four ganache options, and five fruit fillings for an unbelievable mixture. Cake prices start per slice and increase depending on the design’s complexity.

Address: 155 W 18th St, New York, NY 10011

Phone: 646-688-2286

Social: City Cakes

Profile: City Cakes

Contact : Benny Rivera

All, yes ALL, of the baked treats at By The Way Bakery are dairy-free, gluten-free, and certified kosher. CEO Helene Godin has expanded to four locations in New York, so you don’t have to go far to taste test their daily baked goods. Although they have multiple storefronts, By The Way Bakery loves making customized wedding cakes and tiered cakes start per slice, plus the cost of decorations. Designs can include delicate sugar flowers, traditional all-white lace cakes, hand-painted designs, or fondant molded themed cakes.

Address: 2442 Broadway, New York, NY 10024

Phone: 212-877-0806

Social: By The Way Bakery

Profile: By The Way Bakery

Contact : Helene Godin

Empire Cake makes their goodies fresh every day with cream, butter, and other ingredients directly from the local Union Street Market wherever possible. Whether you are interested in a one-of-a-kind cake that matches your wedding theme to a tee or a more traditional tiered cake with classic flavors, their cake consultants can help to make it happen. Cake tastings include six samples from their exciting range of signature flavors. Once you see their beautiful wedding cake designs, we wouldn’t be surprised if you decided to add on a fun groom’s cake to your celebration.

Address: 112 8th Ave New York, NY 10011

Phone: 212-242-5858

Social: Empire Cake

Profile: Empire Cake

Contact : Empire Cake Team

Nikki founded byPensa in 2017 in East Williamsburg. This appointment-only, custom bakery specializes in cakes inspired by natural elements, architecture, and fashion. They are contemporary cakes meant for modern, liberal-minded people that seek originality. The cake designs are quite simply breathtaking, and we don’t doubt that Nikki could do anything she puts her spatula to, whether it be changing the world in the kitchen or the community. The dedication to being a socially conscious and inclusive business is an ethos that we applaud.

Address: New York, NY

Phone: 315-729-9949

Social: byPensa

Profile: byPensa

Contact : Nikki Pensabene

Soma Cakes NYC makes gorgeous cakes. These will be cakes fit to be featured on every bridal magazine’s pages and will blow up on Instagram. What’s most important is that Soma Cake NYC will listen to you and ensure that your cake is precisely in line with your expectations. The minimum order is usually $500 for custom cakes and requires a 50% deposit to hold your date.

Address: 380 E 10th St, New York, NY 10009

Phone: 212-388-1801

Social: Soma Cakes NYC

Profile: Soma Cakes NYC

Contact : Hiroyo Kuramata

Julia Fedorova Cakes is a multi-award-winning bakery based in New York City. Renowned for hyper-realistic, gorgeous florals and edible decorations, these cakes do seem far too pretty to consider cutting into. However, don’t forget that this luscious beauty hides within cake flavors like white chocolate, hazelnut, champagne, or French vanilla. Fillings can include such decadent wonders as sour cherry, orange, or cinnamon apple. Minimum orders are $500 for cakes, mini cupcakes, panna cotta, profiteroles, or truffles.

Address: 349 5th Ave, New York, NY 10016

Phone: 347-652-9905

Social: Julia Fedorova Cakes

Profile: Julia Fedorova Cakes

Contact : Julia Fedorova

A Simple Cake was started in 2009 and has been entrusted to the mastery of baker Nicolle Lugo since 2017. The philosophy remains that the wedding industry needs bakers to provide beautiful cakes that are affordable and easy to order while still quality. A Simple Cake specializes in well-known classic flavors for a reason; they are delicious and remind you of joyful celebrations. Funfetti, chocolate chip, and buttermilk spice are a few of their signature creations. Sample boxes, including three cakes, can be ordered online for pick up or delivery. With A Simple Cake, there is no need to blow your budget to create a gorgeously simple and delicious cake.

Address: New York, NY

Phone: 917-499-2030

Social: A Simple Cake

Profile: A Simple Cake

Contact : Nicolle Lugo

Jesebel Gumogda is the owner and head pastry chef at Pure Confections. Since 2014, she has been specializing in modern cake designs with just the right dash of sweetness. All of their cakes are made by hand using seasonal, fresh ingredients. A cake tasting box can be ordered that includes nine cakes with a flavor description card and a special surprise treat. Their paint-your-own-cookie sets would make fantastic and fun wedding favors!

Address: 1580 Park Avenue, Kitchen 3, New York, NY 10029

Phone: 917-848-3033

Social: Pure Confections

Profile: Pure Confections

Contact : Jesebel Gumogda

Back to Top


Nothing symbolizes a celebration quite as much as having everyone standing around a gorgeous cake. You and your new spouse, grinning from ear to ear and cutting your cake is a picture that you’ll cherish for decades to come.

Back to Top