Of all of the classic wedding day traditions, the cake reveal, and cake cutting is one of the most fun parts of the reception. You want this moment of your wedding day to go off without a hitch. With the right wedding cake baker, you’ll get all you’re looking for out of your wedding cake and more.

To make the process easier for you, we have assembled this list of the top 10 wedding cake bakers in Louisville, Kentucky! No matter how many guests you’re inviting and where you’re celebrating your big day, with the bakers on this list, you’re sure to have a wedding day to remember. We hope you enjoy this list of the top wedding cake bakers in Louisville, Kentucky!

Heitzman Bakery is a bakery that has been serving Louisville for over 12 decades. They offer classic wedding cake flavors, including yellow, Italian, strawberry, cherry, and red velvet. Their services also include buttercream and fondant designs as well as a variety of cake shapes. Delivery is available for a small fee. You can also send the team photos of cakes that inspire you so that they have an idea of your tastes and preferences for the design of your cake.

Address: 3333 Bardstown Road Louisville, KY 40218

Phone: 502-452-1891

Social: Heitzman Bakery

Profile: Heitzman Bakery

Contact : Tony

Sweet Surrender Dessert Cafe is a Louisville-based bakeshop boasting honors and awards from several prestigious publications. Their team of pastry chefs offers up their services as wedding cake bakers and has 25 years of experience in custom cake design. 

Tastings and consultations available by appointment only, at no additional charge to the client. Flavors available for custom cakes include vanilla pound cake, carrot cake, and Italian cream cake. They also have a variety of fillings unique to each cake flavor, including walnuts, cream cheese frosting, coconut sour cream, and others. Wedding cake inquiries can be submitted through the inquiry form on their website. 

Address: 1804 Frankfort Ave Louisville, KY 40206

Phone: 502-899-2008

Social: Sweet Surrender Dessert Cafe

Profile: Sweet Surrender Dessert Cafe

Contact : Jessica Haskell

Sweets by Millie is a wedding cake bakery with a collection of accolades from renowned national publications. They have a history of providing clients with custom cakes that are as delectable as they are decorative. Tastings and consultations are available by appointment for a small fee. 

The team at Sweets by Millie requests that custom cake orders be placed at least six months in advance to ensure that every detail and specification is attended to. The flavors they offer are virtually limitless, from brown sugar pound cake to banana-pecan. Their fillings include bourbon buttercream, lime cream cheese, and lemon curd. Custom cookies and cupcakes are available by request as well, for a twist on the classic wedding cake.

Address: 223 S Hancock Street, Louisville, KY 40202

Phone: 502-488-8312

Social: Sweets by Millie

Profile: Sweets by Millie

Contact : Maggie Hoy

Sugar Fashion Cakes is a wedding cake bakery run by professional pastry chef Sarah Roberts, who has a number of awards from prominent TV networks and publications. When it comes to her custom wedding cakes, she can cook up flavors including mocha latte, snickerdoodle, and Bailey’s Irish cream. 

Sugar Fashion Cakes also offers a number of fillings, including Bavarian cream, chocolate ganache, and chai tea buttercream. Pricing is modeled on a sliding scale according to the size of the client’s guest list, and local delivery is offered for a small fee. Sarah recommends that cake bookings be made 2-3 months in advance of the wedding date.

Address: Okolona Louisville, KY 40219

Phone: 270-234-8043

Social: Sugar Fashion Cakes

Profile: Sugar Fashion Cakes

Contact : Sarah Roberts

Designer Cakes by Angela is a boutique wedding cake company based in Louisville. Angela founded Designer Cakes in 2007 and has been providing unique, custom wedding cakes to couples in and around the city since. Flavor combinations offered include white chocolate with raspberry filling, pink velvet, banana walnut swirl, and Italian cream with toasted pecans and fresh coconut. 

Designer Cakes by Angela also offers an option between buttercream and fondant for the outer coating of your wedding cake. Tastings and consultations can be scheduled by appointment through the contact form on their website.

Address: 8600 Hudson Ln Louisville, KY 40291

Phone: 502-417-7066

Social: Designer Cakes by Angela

Profile: Designer Cakes by Angela

Contact : Angela Dishion

GT Treats is a wedding cake bakery serving the greater Louisville metropolitan area. Owned and operated by Gloria Thompson, this bakery boasts a flavor menu that includes hits as chocolate bourbon, orange creamsicle, and cinnamon roll cupcake. Their fillings range from key lime cream cheese to French buttercream and white chocolate ganache. They also have a gallery available for perusal on their website, and they request that cakes be booked a minimum of three months in advance. Tastings and consultations can be scheduled by appointment only, and delivery is available for a small fee.

Address: 13811 Forest Bend Circle, Louisville, KY 40245

Phone: 502-489-2883

Social: GT Treats

Profile: GT Treats

Contact : Gloria

Emily Wheeler Custom Cakes is a boutique wedding cake company run by Emily Wheeler, who boasts a degree from the French Pastry School of Kennedy King College. This bakery offers flavors such as pina colada, pistachio, and mango. Their buttercreams include Kahlua, mint chocolate, and salted caramel, and fillings include milk chocolate ganache, passionfruit curd, and raspberry conserve. Emily recommends orders for weddings be placed 6-8 months in advance of the celebration date. Tastings and consultations are available by appointment.

Address: Louisville, KY 40223

Phone: 502-533-6365

Social: Emily Wheeler Custom Cakes

Profile: Emily Wheeler Custom Cakes

Contact : Emily

Mert’s Cakes is a Louisville-based wedding cake bakery run by pastry chef Virginia. She combines her passions for sculpting and painting into her craft as a wedding cake designer. Private consultations and tastings with Virginia can be scheduled by appointment. Flavors available include chocolate turtle cake, orange cake with sour cream filling, and toasted almond cake with mocha mousse. Mix and match options are also available for clients to suit individual tastes and preferences.

Address: 11511 Shelbyville Rd.Louisville, Kentucky 40243

Phone: 502-244-6200

Social: Mert's Cakes

Profile: Mert's Cakes

Contact : Virginia Rankin

Sweet By Simone offers couples a vast array of flavors with unique taste profiles such as pink Moscato, peach & cream prosecco, and blackberry lavender. Fillings available include cinnamon brown sugar buttercream, amaretto amarena cherry, Makers Mark spiced buttercream, and white chocolate ganache. Sweet By Simone bakes up rich, decadent wedding cakes with all of the classic ornaments and frills that clients have come to expect. Their website has an inquiry form through which you can place your custom wedding cake orders.

Address: St Matthew Louisville, KY, 40207

Phone: 502-427-0721

Social: Sweet By Simone

Profile: Sweet By Simone

Contact : Simone Fontaine

A Louisville staple, Plehn’s Bakery has been in operation since 1924. The team at this bakery is dedicated to helping you create the wedding cake of your dream. They will work with you to create a cake that incorporates not only your favorite flavors and fillings but also the design of your dreams. 

They offer a wide variety of flavors and fillings: flavors include carrot, spice, Italian cream, and more, while their filling options range from lemon and raspberry to caramel icing and cream cheese icing. Prices are dependant on the size of your cake, the design, and the flavors.

Address: 3940 Shelbyville Rd Louisville, KY 40207

Phone: 502-896-4438

Social: Plehn's Bakery

Contact : Katie McCune

Back to Top


We hope this list has been helpful to you and your partner as you navigate this key aspect of the wedding planning process. No matter whether you’re looking for a multi-tiered dessert that reaches sky high or you’d prefer to keep things simple and delicious with unique, gourmet flavor profiles, we guarantee that Louisville has pastry chefs who can make your cake dreams a reality!

Back to Top