11 Most Popular Wedding Caterers in Columbus, OH (2023)
Choosing a wedding caterer is a massive decision when planning your wedding. You will want to look for a caterer with experience in your preferred type of menu selections and one that can serve in a style that you prefer.
Certainly, the budget is a determining factor; however, remember that there are no rules regarding hosting a reception, so do what makes you happy. If you and your husband are diehard mac n’ cheese fans, then consider incorporating a station into your buffet.
If you would rather mingle and dance the night away, then think about starting later and doing various finger foods and hiring a bartender that can shake a mean martini. It’s all about making memories.
Best Wedding Caterers In Columbus
The Berwick has been dishing out the delectable flavors of Italy since 1955 and is available for both on-site weddings and off-site catering up to 1 hour out of Columbus, Ohio. The Berwick has always been about sharing great food and delivering impeccable service, which continues today. They offer buffets, plated dinners, or serving stations and have menus for breakfast, brunch, lunch, or dinner. Creative dishes like crabmeat stuffed flounder or portabella mushroom ravioli are just two of the dishes that stand out for us. However, they have thought of everything and even have a kids’ station full of healthy treats that your younger guests will love.
Address: 3250 Refugee Road, Columbus, OH 43232
Phone: (614) 235-7100
Profile: The Berwick
Facebook: The Berwick
Instagram: The Berwick
Catering By Scott has been dishing out incredible food for private events in central Ohio for over three decades. They have dedicated menus for cocktail receptions or dinner buffets and can collaborate with you if you would like something specific. The hors d’oeuvre selection includes a wide range of items, including sushi rolls, spanakopita, chicken sate, and mac & cheese balls. Dinner entrees have a definite Italian swing with chicken basil or chicken parmesan. All include lines and service personnel, whereas bartenders may be added at an additional charge.
Address: 2980 E Broad St, Columbus, OH 43209
Phone: (614) 237-1949
Profile: Catering By Scott
Facebook: Catering By Scott
Instagram: Catering By Scott
Exceptional food, professional and impeccable service, and affordable prices are what you want and what you can expect from Milo’s Catering. They have been catering weddings for over twenty years and still manage to make every reception as unique as the couple saying ‘I Do.’ Milo’s Catering has various venue partnerships, styles of services, including buffet, family-style or plated, and menu selections. They will work hand-in-hand with you to devise a perfectly suited menu to your wedding style and preferred tastes.
Address: 980 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43222
Phone: (614) 224-0272
Profile: Milo's Catering
Facebook: Milo's Catering
Instagram: Milo's Catering
Creative Cuisine is a full-service wedding catering company with over four decades of experience in Columbus. They can cater for one aspect of your celebration or take over more of the planning and décor with their professional staff. They even have an on-site floral studio, tasting kitchen, and full bakery right within their rental complex. Creative Cuisine believes in being sustainable and ensuring that they take advantage of organic produce, local farm-fresh goods, and environmentally-friendly disposables. Service styles are varied, including family-style, plated, strolling stations, or hors d’oeuvre receptions. Creative Cuisine has one of the most extensive catering menus that we have ever seen, with more delicious options than we could ever list here.
Address: 839 Busch Court, Columbus, OH 43229
Phone: (614) 436-4949
Profile: Creative Cuisine Catering
Facebook: Creative Cuisine Catering
Instagram: Creative Cuisine Catering
Angela Petro has been in the catering business for over two decades. She continues to showcase her finesse, flair, and attention to detail regarding designing, creating, and curating exceptional menus. At Together & Company, they understand that food is a huge aspect of your wedding, and you will want it to not only be memorable and delicious but inspirational and flawless. You can expect this and more when collaborating with Together & Company on a unique menu for your special day.
Address: 550 S High St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: (614) 882-7323
Profile: Together & Company
Facebook: Together & Company
Instagram: Together & Company
Emelio’s Restaurant & Catering is a family-owned business now run by the second generation of restaurateurs. Whereas the restaurant has been around since the 1960s, they only started offering catering in 2008. Delectable appetizers include bacon-wrapped water chestnuts and cantaloupe chutney bruschetta. Of course, their signature Noni’s Italian Wedding Soup is on the menu, as is an inventive and refreshing mix of salad options. Entrees can include chicken marsala, prime rib, or sliced baked ham with a brown sugar glaze. Speak to them about tailoring a menu perfectly to your wedding theme.
Address: 574 Georgesville Road, Columbus, OH 4322
Phone: (614) 279-7900
Profile: Emelio's Restaurant & Catering
Facebook: Emelio's Restaurant & Catering
Instagram: Emelio's Restaurant & Catering
Hoggy’s Restaurant & Catering is one of the most sought after wedding catering companies to be found across Columbus and beyond, with their exceptional services adding a down-home, casual feeling to wedding parties in the local area. Hoggy’s Restaurant & Catering specializes in barbeque cuisine, with all menu items created by hand and individualized for each wedding party they serve. The specialties include pulled pork and pulled chicken, as well as the delectable mac and cheese and the ribs, wings, brisket, and side dishes. For all barbeque cravings, Hoggy’s Restaurant & Catering can satisfy all guests in attendance at a Columbus-based wedding celebration.
Address: 830 Bethel Rd, Columbus, OH 43214
Facebook: Hoggy's Restaurant & Catering
Instagram: Hoggy's Restaurant & Catering
Look no further than Paddy Wagon for a wedding catering company with a high quality of service and a track record of excellence across the board when it comes to delicious wedding dinners. Paddy Wagon is best known in the local area for its affordability, advertising its services as ⅓ the cost of the other catering companies across Columbus and beyond. For outdoor receptions, Paddy Wagon can create a lighthearted atmosphere, staffed by a friendly team of wedding specialists and wait staff who can set up and break down on their own, keeping things as easy as possible for the happy couple. Typical menu items include brisket sandwiches, grilled cheese, tacos, and other such casual fare.
Address: Columbus, OH
Facebook: Paddy Wagon
Instagram: Paddy Wagon
Executive Chef and owner Stacy Robinson and his wife Jenine have been producing delicious food for years for Taste Of The Best Catering. This company is available for full-service catering, assisted buffet catering, or drop of service. Choose from their selection of menus or speak to the owners about devising a special menu that is perfectly suited to your wedding’s theme and style. Taste Of The Best Catering offers a range of wedding packages from a casual meal set up to elegant dining or action stations where your guests can be more interactive and eat at their leisure. These guys turn out delicious food and are open to trying fresh ideas.
Address: 2-12 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: (614) 358-4559
Profile: Taste Of The Best Catering
Facebook: Taste Of The Best Catering
Steven’s Catering has a wide range of menu options for your wedding reception, whether you are thinking about a champagne brunch, luncheon, formal sit-down dinner, or cocktail party with appetizers. Their full-service offerings include menu selection, food preparation, delivery, set up, wait staff, and clean up. Steven’s Catering also includes china, linens, tables, and chairs, and even an ice sculpture or flowers if this is your preference. They have been in the catering business in Columbus since 2002 and continue to exceed expectations concerning their food and professional service.
Address: 1221 Chesapeake Ave, Columbus, OH 43212
Phone: (614) 486-1221
Profile: Steven's Catering
Facebook: Steven's Catering
City Barbeque and Catering is a fabulous local catering company and restaurant providing unforgettable and delectable barbeque cuisine for wedding parties in and around Columbus. City Barbeque and Catering has been in business for over 20 years, and in this time in business, the chefs and owners have been providing full-service catering with slow-smoked barbeque and delicious sides in cast iron skillets. The wait staff and catering team will bring the cheeriness and fun to a wedding day, while the food will keep all guests in attendance happy and well fed.
Address: 1501 Gemini Pl, Columbus, OH 43240
Facebook: City Barbeque and Catering
Instagram: City Barbeque and Catering
You can see that there is a lot of choice for wedding caterers in Columbus, Ohio, and we have whittled it down to some of the very best in the business with long stating reputations for quality and service. Think about your preferred servicing style and budget, and then give a few caterers a call to see which meshes with your sense of style. The required taste-testing is one of the biggest perks of planning a wedding, after all.
Is your business featured in this article?
Copy the code below and place the code on your website to display the badge award on your website.