Known as a specialty cake bakery, Short North Piece of Cake Bakery & Cafe has been serving the entire Columbus area since 1998. From simple cakes to extraordinary ones, they can help couples bake and decorate delicious art pieces customized to their particular taste. Laura makes sure to put in only fresh ingredients while baking to provide people with unique flavors. Baked and delivered fresh, they have a variety of cakes to accommodate everyone’s needs.

Address: 772 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215

Phone: 614-421-0399

Social: Short North Piece of Cake

Profile: Short North Piece of Cake

Contact : Laura Harter

From custom cakes to luxury cakes, J’s Sweet Treats and Wedding Cakes offer custom-designed sweet treats. Juana M. William started this bakery in 2016 to give recognition to her baking talent. Today, they are known for providing couples with unforgettable memories of cake cutting through edible art. The price they charge for a wedding cake depends on several factors, like design, flavors, and servings. For a custom wedding cake, consider reaching out to the team at least two weeks earlier.

Address: 1540-A Parsons Ave, Columbus, OH 43207

Phone: 614-906-8888

Social: J's Sweet Treats and Wedding Cakes

Profile: J's Sweet Treats and Wedding Cakes

Contact : Juana M. Williams

Resch’s Bakery is a third-generation, family-owned bakery which has been in the business for over a century. Knowing the value of wedding celebrations, they offer perfect cakes with personal attention to flavors and details. The team can craft any kind of tiered confection, from classic style to modern art and so on. Whatever design you have in your mind, talk to their consultant to finalize cake flavors, fillings, toppings, and icings. You can also arrange a cake tasting to make a final choice.

Address: 4061 E Livingston Ave, Columbus, OH 43227

Phone: 614-237-7421

Social: Resch's Bakery

Profile: Resch's Bakery

Contact : Frank X. Resch

Marie decided to follow her passion for baking and designing in 2012 by opening Fate Cakes. Devoted to offering tasty cakes, cake pops, cupcakes, and cookies, this is one of Columbus’s famous bakeries. They have an extended cake menu that features the finest ingredients, resulting in fresh and flavorful cakes. No matter your cake type or wedding venue, they can send their products to any location across Columbus. If you have a specific budget, discuss it with the team during the cake tasting appointment for a better experience.

Address: 1360 Cherry Bottom Road, Columbus, OH 43230

Phone: 614-219-9429

Social: Fate Cakes

Profile: Fate Cakes

Contact : Marie Johns

Specializing in freshly-made, European-style cakes, The Suisse Shop Bakery has been making and serving baked products since 1983. As a leading and full-time bakery, their professional bakers use fresh and quality ingredients to please their clients’ eyes and taste buds. They have made and served thousands of pastries, artistic tortes, and cakes that not just look good but taste delicious as well. Book your cake tasting appointment to decide the best one.

Address: 2119 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH, 43240

Phone: 614-846-5102

Social: The Suisse Shop Bakery

Profile: The Suisse Shop Bakery

Contact : Therese Whitfield

Jan Kish, a culinary artist & master of her craft, is famous for their exquisite cakes and other sweet treats. With over three decades of experience in the baking industry, she gives close attention to details with a personable presence. They have a vast array of flavors, from organic to gluten-free to vegan to cheesecake options. You can choose any combo of cake fillings, flavors, and outer coatings that suit your taste and liking.

Address: 633 Oxford St, Columbus, OH 43085

Phone: 614-848-5855

Social: Jan Kish La Petite Fleur

Contact : Jan Kish

Founded in 2006, Cakes and More has grown from a small home-based shop to a reputed bakery. With state-of-the-art kitchen tools and appliances, they are best-known for their hand-crafting sweet treats made with fresh ingredients. Their priority is to build lifelong relationships with clients by serving made-from-scratch, one-of-a-kind cakes or desserts. From different flavors to fillings to icings and more, you can order a cake of your choice by comparing all available options.

Address: 4969 N. High Street, Columbus, OH 43214

Phone: 614-430-8811

Social: Cakes and More

Profile: Cakes and More

Contact : Adriana

Best-known for customized desserts, Cakes By Kat Bake Shop offers all kinds of sweets, from mini cakes to cupcakes to tiered cakes and all. They customize and design all cakes to meet and exceed couples’ needs. The team can turn a basic cake into a masterpiece by combining the finest ingredients, decorating techniques, and endless flavors. From delicately placed pearls to hand-made flowers, her passion for art and baking can make your cake cutting moment a grand celebration.

Address: Columbus, OH

Social: Cakes By Kat Bake Shop

Profile: Cakes By Kat Bake Shop

Contact : Kat

Capital City Cakes is a family-owned bakery that produces and serves delicious cakes and baked goods. Sue Baisden has over 30 years of experience in baking wedding cakes. Moist fillings, attractive designs, and the incredible taste of their cupcakes, pastries, cakes, and other sweet treats set them apart. Whatever you have in your mind, they can custom your cake with a wide range of flavors, fillings, and icings. Pricing depends on the size and design of a cake.

Address: 4009 Broadway, Grove City, OH 43123

Phone: 614-277-9338

Social: Capital City Cakes

Profile: Capital City Cakes

Contact : Sue Baisden

With over 20 years of experience, Alice Dreischarf strives to bake and deliver fresh and delicious homemade cakes. They keep couples’ desires in mind while baking to enjoy the beauty and taste of their wedding cakes. From a classic to a contemporary cake, their bakers can customize your cake as per your big day theme. Committed to using the freshest ingredients, they have lots of flavors and fillings to pick from. Also, select your cake flavor, filling, and icing after the tasting.

Address: 2433 Home Rd, Powell, OH 43065

Phone: 740-917-9031

Social: Alice's Piece of Cake

Profile: Alice's Piece of Cake

Contact : Alice

Back to Top


The cake cutting is one of the most awaited moments of a wedding ceremony. Obviously, the size of the cake depends on your gathering. Just talk to one of these bakers, discuss how many people will be a part of your ceremony, and then finalize the size and taste of your wedding cake.

Back to Top