5 Best Wedding Caterers in New Haven, CT

Shaken and Stirred Catered Events stands out among wedding caterers in New Haven, CT, for their commitment to restaurant-quality dining and craft beverages. They use the highest quality, freshest ingredients, often sourced locally in Connecticut, ensuring exceptional flavors in every dish. Their passion for mixology shines through with specialty cocktails crafted by expert bartenders, adding a unique touch to any celebration. With a focus on creating lasting memories, Shaken and Stirred Catered Events delivers an unforgettable culinary experience for your special day.

Address: 266 College St, New Haven, CT 06510

Phone: 203-850-7731

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Benny and Ephrat founded The Gusto Kitchen in 2014, bringing their passion for food from a small Brooklyn kitchen to New Haven, CT. As one of the top wedding caterers in the area, they custom tailor each event to the client’s vision. Their skilled staff can create a diverse array of cuisines, from Indian and Mexican to Asian and classic European. Every dish is crafted to be delicious and unforgettable. With Benny’s extensive training and experience in the culinary industry, The Gusto Kitchen has grown from unique gourmet sandwiches to catering exquisite private parties, making them a standout choice for your wedding celebration.

Address: 357 Whalley Ave #1B, New Haven, CT 06511

Phone: 203-553-5553

Social: Facebook | Instagram

With The Farm Belly, wedding caterers in New Haven, CT, bring the farm’s freshness straight to your plate. Their commitment to using locally-sourced ingredients from Connecticut farms ensures vibrant flavors and quality in every dish. Led by award-winning chef Meg Fama, whose culinary journey began in her grandmother’s kitchen, The Farm Belly embodies a passion for fresh, seasonal ingredients. Meg’s dedication to supporting local farmers and utilizing their produce shines through in each customized menu. From field to fork, The Farm Belly promises a farm-to-table experience that celebrates the best of Connecticut’s agricultural bounty for your wedding day.

Address: New Haven, CT

Phone: 203-361-7212

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Catering to New Haven, CT weddings, Café George By Paula brings fresh, innovative cuisine to your special day. Founded in 2003 by chef Paula Konareski, their daily menu boasts soups, vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options, all made from quality, seasonal ingredients. Whether it’s a backyard picnic or a seaside wedding, they cater to events of all sizes with customizable menus designed to impress every guest. Paula’s flair for presentation and attention to detail ensures that each dish is both delicious and memorable. With courteous and professional staff handling every detail, couples can relax and enjoy their wedding celebration while Café George By Paula takes care of the culinary experience.

Address: 300 George St #101, New Haven, CT 06511

Phone: 203-777-1414

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Crafting bespoke culinary experiences, Small Kitchen Big Taste is a standout among wedding caterers in New Haven, CT. With a commitment to fresh, delicious fare and genuine hospitality, they ensure that every celebration is unforgettable. Led by owner Karen Lenahan, whose passion for food and creativity drives the company, SKBT tailors each menu to reflect the season, venue, and couple’s vision. From intimate gatherings to grand receptions, they infuse every event with warmth, love, and exceptional cuisine. For couples seeking a truly personalized wedding dining experience, Small Kitchen Big Taste delivers magic on every plate.

Address: 420 Sackett Point Rd, North Haven, CT 06473

Phone: 475-238-8470

Social: Facebook | Instagram