Crème de la Cocoa

In the heart of St. Augustine, there’s a bakery dedicated to making wedding days unforgettable with stunning and delicious cakes and desserts. Offering a variety of flavors, from classic favorites to custom creations, they ensure every couple’s dessert dreams come to life. Whether it’s a simple, rustic design or an elaborate showstopper, they have the expertise to craft it. Couples are invited to start the journey with a complimentary consultation, available both in-person with tastings or via phone with samples to go. For those not in the area or short on time, cake samples can also be ordered for pickup or shipping. However, it’s noted that while they strive to accommodate allergy requests, their bakery products may contain common allergens.

Address: 299 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine, FL 32084

Phone: 904-466-9499

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Contact : Nils & Bailey

LuLi's Cupcakes

Discover a sweet slice of St. Augustine’s history with a bakery that has been delighting couples since 2008. Specializing in custom wedding cakes, cupcake displays, and dessert bars, this bakery is renowned for its stunning creations that are as beautiful as they are delicious. With a focus on their signature buttercream frosting, they offer a broad palette of flavors and fillings tailored to each couple’s tastes. Nestled in the historic “uptown” area, they’re dedicated to making your special day even more memorable with their exceptional treats. Looking forward to discussing your wedding’s details, they’re excited to craft the perfect centerpiece for your celebration.

Address: 82 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine, FL 32084

Phone: 904-824-5280

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Contact : LuLi's Cupcakes Team

The Sweet City Cupcakes

Indulge in a little bliss with each bite from a bakery that boasts over 20 years of experience in St. Augustine. Specializing in custom edible art, they offer a dazzling array of over 50 flavors for showstopper cakes, cupcakes, and mini desserts suited for any special event, big or small. Led by head baker Patricia Kenyon and master decorator Dana Blanton, their team is committed to bringing your wedding cake dreams to life. Welcoming custom requests, they also cater to specific dietary needs with gluten-free and vegan options available upon request. Seasonal flavors enrich their already extensive selection, ensuring there’s always something new to taste and love for your special celebration.

Address: 233 W King St # A, St. Augustine, FL 32084

Phone: 904-342-2119

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Contact : Dana


For those seeking a memorable addition to their wedding in St. Augustine, look no further than a charming bakery nestled at 47 Cordova Street. Renowned for crafting the centerpiece of your reception, this woman-owned and operated café, formerly known as the Chocolate Turtle, has reemerged as ChocoLattes with a fresh look yet retains the beloved desserts fans adore. Offering a variety of services from custom wedding and groom’s cakes to delightful dessert tables, they ensure every sweet desire is met. Their dedication to creating unique, scratch-made desserts in a cozy atmosphere makes them a standout. Schedule a free consultation to start planning the sweetest part of your special day. With their attention to detail and passion for baking, your wedding dessert will surely be unforgettable.

Address: 47 Cordova St, St. Augustine, FL 32084

Phone: 904-436-5813

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Contact : Lisa Dallaire

Kristen’s Cupcake Café

Explore the sweet side of St. Augustine with a visit to a delightful bakery that brings joy through its custom cakes, cupcakes, and more. This gem in the heart of Florida’s historic city caters to all your celebratory needs with a variety of sweet treats that can even be made vegan upon request. The team, passionate about creating memorable moments for your special events, is ready to bring your dessert dreams to life. Licensed and insured, they guarantee not only exquisite taste but also peace of mind for your big day. Whether you’re planning a wedding or any special occasion, their commitment to quality and customization makes them a top choice for those looking to indulge in life’s sweetest moments.

Address: St. Augustine, FL

Phone: 407-690-8279

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Contact : Kristen

Sweets & Treats

Kristen’s Cupcake Café, nestled in the heart of North East Florida, brings the sweet magic of homemade treats to life under the skilled hands of Christina, a certified pastry chef with a knack for storytelling through desserts. With roots in New York and a degree in Baking & Pastry Arts, Christina’s self-taught decorating skills shine in every creation. From buttercream to fondant and beyond, each cake is a testament to her passion and dedication to baking. Whether it’s standard, themed, shaped, or sculpted cake, Kristen’s Cupcake Café promises to add a touch of enchantment to any wedding, backed by a commitment to accommodate even the most last-minute requests, ensuring every couple’s celebration is both sweet and memorable.

Address: Palm Coast, FL

Phone: 904-878-7328

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Contact : Christina

Back to Top


Your wedding cake is a testament to your celebration, a fusion of artistry and taste that eloquently expresses the essence of your special day. In St. Augustine, the right baker can transform your vision into a delicious reality, leaving a lasting impression on you and your guests.

Our article has guided you through the best wedding cake bakers in the area, emphasizing the importance of taste, creativity, and professionalizm. Good research, like reading our recommendations, ensures you’ll find a baker who can exceed your expectations.

As you finalize your choice, remember that the perfect wedding cake adds sweetness to your memories and joy to your celebration. Here’s to a beautiful, tasty cake that complements your perfect day!

Back to Top