Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery is a traditional Dutch bakery open for business for Colorado Springs wedding celebrations since 1999. Boasting honors and awards from a bevy of publications, Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery brings the traditions of Dutch cuisine to the art of pastry. Their custom wedding cakes also include either American or European buttercream icing. You can check out their website gallery for a sampling of their design sensibilities, as well as their flavor combinations.

Address: 610 E Fillmore St Colorado Springs, CO 80907

Phone: 719-264-0177

Profile: Boonzaaijer's Dutch Bakery

Facebook: Boonzaaijer's Dutch Bakery

Contact : Stephen Boonzaaijer

The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe is a wedding cake company that has been in business since 2010. Founded by Amanda Adams, this bakery provides custom-made wedding cakes to clients around the local area and beyond. Flavors include funfetti, Italian wedding, pistachio, and pink champagne with fillings, including white chocolate buttercream, strawberry lemonade, and coconut pecan. Complimentary tastings and consultations can be scheduled by appointment. Boasting accolades from several national wedding publications, The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe can provide elegant wedding cakes for celebrations of all sizes.

Address: 412 S 8th St Colorado Springs, CO 80905

Phone: 719-930-3343

Profile: The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe

Facebook: The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe

Instagram: The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe

Contact : Amanda Adams

Icing on the Cake is a wedding cake boutique providing couples in and around Colorado Springs with memorable custom wedding cakes. Complimentary tastings and consultations can be scheduled by appointment. These appointments last up to one hour and include six distinct flavors and fillings. Flavors available for custom wedding cakes include German chocolate, raspberry, coconut, and almond, among other such classics. Fillings available include white chocolate buttercream, orange chiffon, and salted caramel. Pies, cupcakes, and various pastries can be made available upon request for couples that are looking for a different spin to a traditional wedding cake.

Address: 15 N Union Blvd Colorado Springs, CO 80909

Phone: 719-633-5151

Profile: Icing on the Cake

Facebook: Icing on the Cake

Contact : Mischa Halberg

Iced and Dazzle is an award-winning wedding cake company providing top-notch custom cakes to couples in the greater Colorado Springs metropolitan area. Owned and operated by pastry chef Linda, Iced and Dazzle can cook up cakes in such creative flavors as Chinese five-spice, chocolate gingerbread, and golden butter with buttercreams including orange cinnamon hibiscus, and salted caramel. Premium buttercreams include triple berry, amaretto, Irish creme, and honey lemon. Tastings and consultations are held by appointment and for a small fee.

Address: Colorado Springs, CO

Phone: 719-466-0837

Profile: Iced and Dazzle

Facebook: Iced and Dazzle

Instagram: Iced and Dazzle

Contact : Linda Cloutier

Bella Cakes By Thena is a wedding cake company based in Colorado Springs, providing local couples with sophisticated cake designs perfect for elegant wedding celebrations. Flavors available for custom cakes include white almond sour cream cake filled with white chocolate truffle filling and apricot preserves, white buttermilk cake filled with salted honey buttercream, and pistachio almond cake filled with whipped pistachio cheesecake filling. Premium flavors and mix-and-match flavoring options can be provided as well. Complimentary tastings and consultations are available by appointment. Free delivery is available for weddings in Colorado Springs, with a fee added if you are outside of the Colorado Springs area.

Address: Thistlewood Street Colorado Springs, CO 80923

Phone: 719-352-6214

Profile: Bella Cakes By Thena

Facebook: Bella Cakes By Thena

Instagram: Bella Cakes By Thena

Contact : Thena

American Pie Bakery has been serving custom cakes for weddings in and around Colorado Springs since 2000. Boasting a collection of several honors and awards from prominent national and statewide wedding publications, American Pie Bakery offers mix-and-match options for flavors. They also offer a list of “favorite combinations,” which includes chocolate cake filled with almond and coconut buttercream, vanilla cake filled with white chocolate ganache and fresh caramel, and lemon cake filled with raspberry buttercream and raspberry preserve, covered in lemon buttercream. Cake tasting boxes are available upon request. They ask that clients place orders sooner rather than later, though orders a few weeks in advance of the wedding date can usually be accommodated.

Address: Monument, Colorado

Profile: American Pie Bakery

Facebook: American Pie Bakery

Contact : Irene Barba

Fiesta Cakes is the right place to be for all your wedding cake dreams in Colorado Springs! Situated right at the city’s heart, this is a go-to spot for delightful wedding cakes that add a touch of magic to your big day. With cakes that are not only visually stunning but also incredibly delicious, Fiesta Cakes knows how to make your celebration extra special. From classic designs to modern creations, they craft cakes that reflect your unique love story. With a selection of flavors and designs, Fiesta Cakes is the perfect choice to bring your wedding cake vision to life in the most delicious way possible!

Address: 3018 Monica Dr W, Colorado Springs, CO 80916

Phone: 337-517-5953

Facebook: Fiesta Cakes

Instagram: Fiesta Cakes

Contact : Ariel Cates

The Cupcake Doctor in Colorado Springs is a top pick for fantastic wedding cupcakes! Cupcakes are the hottest wedding trend, and the Cupcake Doctor knows just how to make your big day even more special. Imagine a stunning cupcake tower filled with various flavors and designs that traditional cakes cannot match. Not only will your guests be amazed, but you will also cut costs! They even match colors to your invitations and include personal touches for a unique display. The Cupcake Doctor offers more than just cupcakes. They offer services like couple’s cakes, groom’s cakes, and even first anniversary cupcakes. From bridal showers to bachelorette parties, they have got you covered!

Address: 3312 Austin Bluffs Pkwy Colorado Springs, CO 80918

Phone: 719-271-0990

Facebook: The Cupcake Doctor

Instagram: The Cupcake Doctor

Contact : Desirae Leipply

Back to Top


We hope that this list of the very best wedding cake bakers in Colorado Springs has been helpful to you and your partner as you enter this chapter of the wedding planning process. As you browse your options, we encourage you to reach out to as many wedding cake bakers as you find appealing. This will help you compare and contrast flavors, prices, delivery options, and more. If your wedding is taking place during a busy celebration season, there’s no time like the present to start opening those lines of communication with potential cake bakers. After all, with a baker chosen, you’ll have a delicious and beautiful wedding cake to look forward to as your wedding date approaches! 

Back to Top