20+ Best Wedding Jewelry Stores in New York, NY (2023)

Located in the heart of Manhattan, Rêve Diamonds is an internationally renowned jeweler with an outstanding reputation for engagement rings and an extensive collection of lab-grown and natural diamond rings to choose from.

Rêve’s team prides itself on excellent customer service and offers personal one-to-one jeweler consultation experiences with appointments available on weekdays and Saturdays. Rêve also offers a custom design service with only a two-week lead time so you can create the perfect engagement ring for your partner in time for your proposal.

As a manufacturer and distributor, Rêve offers retail customers wholesale prices of 20-40% less than their competitors. Their team of diamond experts are masters of the latest jewelry-making techniques. So whether you’re looking for a classic design or something more unique, explore Rêve Diamonds’ collection today.

Address: 745 5th Avenue,10151, New York, NY

Phone: 646-898-2098

Instagram: Rêve Diamonds

Forever Diamonds has been family-owned since 1981. Their team continues to follow with their original goal of providing exceptional customer service combined with unique handcrafted jewelry designs. Collaborations can be done remotely or in person, where a Forever Diamonds expert will guide you through the process from stone selection through choosing a setting and the various payment options available.

Custom pieces at this store typically take 4-6 weeks to complete. However, unlike many jewelers, Forever Diamonds are willing to work with a diamond you might already have, as their focus is on the exquisite craftsmanship of the setting itself. This means that if you have inherited a sentimental heirloom diamond, you can craft the jewelry of your dreams and keep it with tradition.

Address: 66 West 47th Street, Booth # 37 & 38, New York, NY 10036

Phone: (855) 438-3769

Facebook: Forever Diamonds

Instagram: Forever Diamonds

Lauren B was founded in New York City’s famed Diamond District by a husband and wife team that remains passionate about one-of-a-kind rings and gorgeous settings. Since their bespoke beginnings, Lauren B has evolved into a jewelry company more focused on engagement rings, wedding bands, and loose diamonds. They have a number of trademark designs that are highly sought-after and have catapulted the brand to international recognition.

Lauren B is an excellent option if you are unsure of what type of wedding jewelry you are looking for or what stones you wish to consider. Their focus on educating their clients means that you don’t need to feel pressured into buying anything you are sure about, as their design consultants will guide you through the process. In addition, ask them about trade-in options for your diamond or future upgrade possibilities.

Address: 44 E 46th St, New York, NY 10017

Phone: (212) 869-4731

Facebook: Lauren B

Instagram: Lauren B

Since 2001, Micahel and Hiroyo Fitzgerald have proudly served Brooklyn and the entire globe with fine jewelry, specializing in custom engagement rings and wedding bands. You can shop for white diamond rings, gemstone rings, and more. From plain and stone bands to matching sets, your wedding jewelry will reflect your personality and love. Designers include Hiroyo, Nishi, Ruowei, Vena Amoris, Bree Altman, and more. Custom matrimony jewelry is also available, allowing you to work with a team of designers to bring your ideas to life. Fitzgerald Jewelry also provides expert repairs so your jewelry lasts for a lifetime, just like your love for each other! 

Address: 243 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Phone: 718-387-6200

Facebook: Fitzgerald Jewelry

Instagram: Fitzgerald Jewelry

With a dedication to customer satisfaction and a passion for exquisite craftsmanship, Tivoli Jewelers has been a staple of the community. Frank owns Tivoli Jewelers and has been a trusted jeweler for decades, offering the best in quality products and hospitality. You can find stunning engagement rings, wedding bands, necklaces, pendants, bracelets, earrings, and watches at Tivoli Jewelers. Shop by settings like a double halo, solitaire, or split shank, or browse by designers such as Gabriel & Co., Benchmark, and Tivoli Jewelers. Custom jewelry is also available. Simply request a quote, discuss the concept, view CAD and wax models, and fall in love with your one-of-a-kind ring from this reliable wedding jewelry store in Brooklyn.

Address: 327 Graham Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Phone: 718-384-1305

Facebook: Tivoli Jewelers

Instagram: Tivoli Jewelers

Founded in 2004, this famous wedding jewelry store in Brooklyn has an intimate and personal approach to fine jewelry. From quiet luxury and instant heirlooms to 14k solid gold and diamonds, you will find items you adore. This sustainable wedding jewelry store in Brooklyn uses 95% recycled gold and ethically-sourced stones. Shop for gorgeous engagement rings and wedding bands from designers like Wwake, Jennie Kwon, Kataoka, Sofia Zakia, Bittersweets NY, Catbird Wedding, and more. Besides rings, necklaces, bracelets, charms, lockets, chains, and anklets, you can find gifts, candles, nail polish, and other home and beauty products at Catbird. Ask about ready-to-ship items, new arrivals, custom options, and sales. 

Address: 108 N 7th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249

Phone: 718-599-3457

Facebook: Catbird

Instagram: Catbird

Address: 1639 Richmond Rd, Staten Island, NY 10304

Phone: 718-351-8300

Facebook: Casale Jewelers

Instagram: Casale Jewelers

Address: 2655 Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314

Phone: 718-698-7075

Facebook: Goff Jewelers

Instagram: Goff Jewelers

Address: 1250 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305

Phone: 718-448-4900

Facebook: Buono Jewelers

Instagram: Buono Jewelers

Address: 1063 Morris Park Ave, The Bronx, NY 10461

Phone: 718-829-5815

Facebook: Caputo Jewelers

Instagram: Caputo Jewelers

Address: 200 Baychester Ave Suite 125, The Bronx, NY 10475

Phone: 718-862-4065

Facebook: Kay Jewelers

Instagram: Kay Jewelers

Address: 2521 Webster Ave, The Bronx, NY 10458

Phone: 718-933-3003

Facebook: Rocco's Jewelry

Instagram: Rocco's Jewelry

Address: 36-05 162nd St, Flushing, NY 11358

Phone: 718-445-7272

Facebook: Rizos Jewelry

Address: 185-12 Union Turnpike, Fresh Meadows, NY 11366

Phone: 718-264-1200

Facebook: Sophie's Creations

Instagram: Sophie's Creations

Address: 89 53A 165th St, Queens, NY 11432

Phone: 718-206-2870

Facebook: Jamaica Jewelry Outlet

Instagram: Jamaica Jewelry Outlet

Located in the heart of Manhattan, Rêve Diamonds is an internationally renowned jeweler with an outstanding reputation for engagement rings and an extensive collection of lab-grown and natural diamond rings to choose from.

Rêve’s team prides itself on excellent customer service and offers personal one-to-one jeweler consultation experiences with appointments available on weekdays and Saturdays. Rêve also offers a custom design service with only a two-week lead time so you can create the perfect engagement ring for your partner in time for your proposal.

As a manufacturer and distributor, Rêve offers retail customers wholesale prices of 20-40% less than their competitors. Their team of diamond experts are masters of the latest jewelry-making techniques. So whether you’re looking for a classic design or something more unique, explore Rêve Diamonds’ collection today.

Address: 745 5th Ave, Manhattan, NY 10151

Phone: 646-898-2098

Instagram: Rêve Diamonds

Shop a large selection of in-stock collections today at Lauren B Jewelry & Diamonds, and if you can’t find the perfect ring, work one-on-one with a trained and talented design consulate to create your own custom style. Select a design, view diamonds and gems, and you are on your way to getting the most essential jewelry ever from this Manhattan jewelry store. Natural diamonds, moissanite, lab-ready, and color stones are available. You can shop exclusive collections, like Pave Prongs, Invisible Gallery, Signature Wrap, and Hidden Halo, at Lauren B Jewelry & Diamonds. Visit the NY showroom in midtown Manhattan and browse the extensive collection today at Lauren B Jewelry & Diamonds.

Address: 44 E 46th St, New York, NY 10017

Phone: 212-391-0633

Facebook: Lauren B Jewelry & Diamonds

Instagram: Lauren B Jewelry & Diamonds

Celebrate life’s milestones with diamonds from Haniken Jewelers New York. Established in 1985, the Hanikens have been creating custom fine jewelry for four decades. Michael is a diamond gemologist and hand-selects every diamond, including GIA-certified ones. This family business focuses on the best in customer satisfaction. From engagement rings and wedding bands to gifts and bespoke pieces, you will discover exquisite luxury at Haniken Jewelers New York. Browse benchmark wedding, eternity, stackable, and traditional bands. Henri Daussi and other designers are showcased at Haniken Jewelers New York. Necklaces, including personalized initial necklaces, earrings, and more, are also available from this top wedding jewelry store in Manhattan.

Address: 66 W 47th St, New York, NY 10036

Phone: 212-302-6605

Facebook: Haniken Jewelers New York

Instagram: Haniken Jewelers New York

You can trust Ryan, graduate gemologist and owner of Spears & Co., to assist you and educate you through the ring purchasing process. There are a number of unique settings and bands to try on in the studio, or you can use the magnetic ring builder to create your own masterpiece. Custom jewelry goes from an idea to a sketch to your hands in about three to four weeks. You’ll receive certified natural diamonds, gemstones, or whatever else you request from Spears & Co. Vintage and estate jewelry is also available at Spears & Co. Ask about ring sizing, stone replacement, prong work, repair, cleaning, polishing, and other services. Walk-ins and appointments are welcome at Spears & Co.

Address: 822 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222

Phone: 716-341-0130

Facebook: Spears & Co.

Instagram: Spears & Co.

Fall in love with fine jewelry from Bomi Jewelers. This top-rated wedding jewelry store in Buffalo has proudly served happy couples within the community since 1935. They have a reputation for professionalism and quality with an internally-recognized staff of dedicated experts. These professionals will teach you about metal types, ring styles, setting options, gemstones, diamonds, and more, so you can select the perfect one. Bomi Jewelers offers bracelets, earrings, necklaces, engagement rings, wedding bands, and more. On-site custom jewelry designs are also available from Bomi Jewelers, so you can create a dream come true for your lover. Ask about resizing, repairs, and other helpful services from Bomi Jewelers.

Address: 4574 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14226

Phone: 716-839-4300

Facebook: Bomi Jewelers

Instagram: Bomi Jewelers

Discover a ring that sings your love story from Alexis Russell Jewelry. You can shop for ethically-sourced and one-of-a-kind engagement rings, wedding bands, and more. Unique collections at Alexis Russell Jewelry include the Rainbow Sapphire Collection, the Candy Gemstone Collection, the Montana Sapphire Collection, the Ruby Collection, the Pride Collection, the Keshi Pearl Collection, and many more. Each piece is uniquely meaningful, born from fire, pressure, and earth, and brought to life in this Buffalo studio. Alexis is passionate about art, design, geology, and creating curated pieces using stones to tell a story. Everything is handcrafted with love. Ask about diamond engagement rings, gemstone options, ready-to-ship rings, custom styles, wedding bands, and men’s to get started.

Address: Buffalo, NY

Phone: 716-445-6618

Facebook: Alexis Russell Jewelry

Instagram: Alexis Russell Jewelry

Address: 3547 James St, Syracuse, NY 13206

Phone: 315-463-1555

Facebook: Jewelry On James

Instagram: Jewelry On James

Address: 300 S Warren St, Syracuse, NY 13202

Phone: 315-422-7228

Facebook: M. Lemp Jewelers

Instagram: M. Lemp Jewelers

Address: 4 Destiny USA Drive Space B209, Syracuse, NY 13204

Phone: 315-466-1301

Facebook: Hannoush Jewelers

Instagram: Hannoush Jewelers